⭐ 100% Authentic Autographs • COA Included • Lifetime Guarantee
🚚 Free Shipping on Orders $149+ (excludes signings & mail-ins)
🔥 Bobby Clarke Private Signing! Lock in your orders by August 31

New York Islanders Autographed Memorabilia

Signed New York Islanders Photos, Pucks & Jerseys

New York Islanders autographed memorabilia celebrates a franchise defined by its early 1980s Stanley Cup dynasty and generations of beloved Long Island hockey stars.

Shop hand-signed New York Islanders hockey collectibles at SportAuthentix, including autographed 8x10 photos, signed hockey pucks, autographed jerseys, and authentic NHL memorabilia.

Each signed item includes a SportAuthentix tamper-proof hologram and Certificate of Authenticity (COA). Every item is backed by our 100% lifetime authenticity guarantee.

Browse available New York Islanders autographs and signed hockey memorabilia below.

  • Sort by

Save 43%
Bob Nystrom autographed New York Islanders hockey puck, featuring the teams logo and a clear silver signature above the emblem.

Bob Nystrom New York Islanders Autographed Puck

$20.00
$20.00
$34.99

Sold Out
Autographed New York Islanders puck signed by Pierre Turgeon (#77), includes Certificate of Authenticity (COA).

Pierre Turgeon New York Islanders Autographed Puck

$25.00
$25.00
$44.99
Save 33%
Brent Sutter New York Islanders signed black puck, inscribed SC 82-83, presented with Certificate of Authenticity.

Brent Sutter New York Islanders Autographed Puck

$30.00
$30.00
$44.99

Save 34%
This autographed 8x10 photo features all six Sutter brothers with hockey sticks, accompanied by a Certificate of Authenticity.

The Sutter Brothers Autographed 8x10

$125.00
$125.00
$189.99

Save 37%
Billy Harris autographed New York Islanders puck with Islanders 1st Pick inscription

Billy Harris Autographed New York Islanders Hockey Puck - Islanders 1st Pick

$25.00
$25.00
$39.99
Save 46%
Signed 8x10 photo of Gerry Desjardins in New York Islanders gear blocking a puck, collectible autographed photograph.

Gerry Desjardins New York Islanders Autographed 8x10

$15.00
$15.00
$27.99

Save 36%
Dual-signed New York Islanders hockey puck autographed by Brent Sutter & Duane Sutter—authentic collectible memorabilia.

Brent Sutter & Duane Sutter New York Islanders Dual Autographed Puck

$45.00
$45.00
$69.99
Save 29%
Brent Sutter inscribed 8x10 photo celebrating NY Islanders Stanley Cup, featuring his autograph and Certificate of Authenticity.

Brent Sutter New York Islanders Stanley Cup Autographed 8x10

$25.00
$25.00
$34.99
Sold Out
Pat Lafontaine New York Islanders Rookie signed 8x10 photo, inscribed and autographed, shows him in full uniform on the ice.

Pat Lafontaine New York Islanders Rookie Autographed 8x10

$30.00
$30.00
$49.99
Save 27%
The Sutter Brothers 11x14 photo, autographed by all six players, features Brent Sutter signing over a yellow-white background.

The Sutter Brothers Autographed 11x14

$145.00
$145.00
$199.99
Save 29%
Duane Sutter autographed 8x10 photo featuring the New York Islanders Stanley Cup, a premium collectible for hockey enthusiasts.

Duane Sutter New York Islanders Stanley Cup Autographed 8x10

$25.00
$25.00
$34.99
Save 33%
Felix Potvin autographed New York Islanders 8x10 photo with The Cat inscription

Felix Potvin Autographed New York Islanders 8x10 Photo

$30.00
$30.00
$44.99
Sold Out
Authentic Al Arbour New York Islanders Autographed Puck - SportAuthentix

Al Arbour New York Islanders Autographed Puck

$105.00
$105.00
$129.99
Sold Out
Authentic Mike Bossy New York Islanders HOF Autographed Puck - SportAuthentix

Mike Bossy New York Islanders HOF Autographed Puck

$249.99
$249.99
$249.99
Save 34%
The Sutter Brothers Collage Autographed 8x10 is a signed photo print, featuring all six brothers NHL action images with signatures.

The Sutter Brothers Collage Autographed 8x10

$125.00
$125.00
$189.99
Save 14%
Richard Brodeur autographed New York Islanders hockey puck

Richard Brodeur Autographed New York Islanders Hockey Puck

$25.00
$25.00
$28.99